I Became a Surrogate for My BIL and His Wife – When He Saw the Baby, He Yelled, ‘This Must Be a Mistake!’

 

After nine years of marriage, I thought I’d heard it all. But then my husband, Mark, surprised me with a question one evening.

“Babe,” he said, hesitantly fiddling with his beer bottle. “What would you think about being a surrogate for Liam and Sarah?”

I stared at him. “You’re joking.”

He shook his head, his face serious.

The room went quiet, the TV humdrum in the background. I couldn’t process it. Liam and Sarah had always been close—fun, the couple everyone adored—but this? This was out of the blue.

“Just hear me out,” Mark continued. “They’ve tried everything. IVF didn’t work. Adoption’s taking too long. They’re heartbroken. You know how much they want this.”

He wasn’t wrong. I’d seen Sarah in tears at Christmas, unable to bear someone else’s baby photos. And Liam, always the clown, wore a forced smile with every pregnancy announcement.

“They’ll cover everything—medical bills, compensation—and… they offered enough for Emma’s college fund,” Mark added, his voice trailing off.

That last part hit me hard. Emma, our eight-year-old daughter, dreamed of becoming an astronaut, and college wasn’t cheap.

After weeks of research, tears, and tough conversations, I agreed. I hoped that helping Liam and Sarah find happiness would be worth the sleepless nights and awkward moments.

Nine months later, the delivery went smoothly. But as the doctor handed me the baby, I noticed something that stopped my heart. Her skin was dark.

Confusion struck me. This wasn’t what I’d expected.

Liam and Sarah entered, and I handed them their daughter. For a brief moment, I saw a flicker of joy in Sarah’s eyes—but then, silence.

Liam’s voice broke through the quiet. “This must be a mistake. This can’t be our child!”

Sarah froze, her voice barely a whisper. “What… what do you mean?”

Confusion twisted my stomach. “What’s wrong?” I asked.

Liam backed away. “Look at her! This isn’t my child! This is impossible!”

Sarah’s tears fell freely. “She’s not ours.”

My heart sank as Liam placed her in the bassinet with a coldness that stung. Sarah reached for his arm, but he yanked it away.

“We didn’t agree to this!” Liam shouted.

“Liam, wait!” I cried, but he was already leaving, dragging Sarah with him.

I slumped beside the bassinet, whispering, “It’s not a mistake. It’s not…”

The next morning, I confronted the doctor, seeking answers. She explained that recessive genes could cause traits like darker skin to appear unexpectedly, especially in families with mixed ancestry.

Mark later confronted Liam, and a DNA test confirmed the baby was his. But Liam’s reaction wasn’t what we hoped for. He refused to accept her.

Determined, Mark stormed to Liam’s house, demanding he take responsibility. “You’re the father. She’s your daughter,” he said.

But Liam, cold and distant, refused. “I can’t bring her home. Do you know what people will say?”

Mark was stunned. “So you’re rejecting her because of gossip?”

Liam didn’t answer. He just walked away.

At home, my heart broke. The baby’s bassinet remained untouched. Her birth certificate was still blank.

One night, I turned to Mark, tears in my eyes. “What if we adopted her?”

Mark’s eyes softened. “I was hoping you’d say that.”

A few months later, we signed the adoption papers. Our family felt complete, even though this wasn’t the life we had planned.

When we brought her home, Emma’s face lit up. “Is she really my sister now?”

“She’s always been your sister,” Mark said with a smile, placing the baby in Emma’s arms.

Emma cradled her gently. “Hi, baby. I’m your big sister.”

Mark wrapped his arm around me, and I leaned into him. Our family of four was perfect.

As for Liam? He paid the surrogacy fee in full, sending a curt message through his lawyer. No apology, just a confirmation of the contract.

“Do you think he feels guilty?” Mark asked one evening.

I stroked the baby’s tiny hand. “Maybe. Or maybe it’s easier for him to just write a check than face what he did.”

Liam and Sarah kept their distance. At first, it hurt to be disconnected from people we once considered family, but over time, I realized we didn’t need their approval.

We had everything we needed right here.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*