It was a simple white mug, trimmed in gold, with “Best Dad” in shiny letters. A bit tacky, but oddly touching—especially since Gina had never given me anything before.
I brought it home, still turning the moment over in my head.
“Your mom said she bought this just for me,” I called to Hailey, placing it on the counter.
She walked in, holding a basket of socks. One glance at the mug, and the color drained from her face. Without a word, she crossed the kitchen, took it, and smashed it in the sink.
“What the hell?” I asked.
Her voice was barely a whisper. “It used to be my dad’s.”
I was stunned. Gina had said Elliot called me the Best Dad, so she wanted me to have it.
“No,” Hailey said quietly. “She always does this. After he died, she started giving his things away—like party favors. His watch, his jacket, now this mug… the one he used every morning until the day he died.”
She moved through the kitchen, calm but tightly wound, grounding herself against the counter.
“That mug wasn’t a gift. It was a memory. A ritual. Dad’s way of holding back the chaos for a few quiet minutes.”
I saw it then—the worn handle, the faded lettering.
Gina hadn’t meant it as kindness. It was control. She’d never forgiven Sandy for dying. So she scattered pieces of him, like breaking him apart would make the grief easier to carry.
Later, I found Hailey picking through the shards. She placed the biggest one, the words Best Dad still intact, into a paper bag.
“She does this to punish us,” she said. “Wraps it up like love. But it’s not.”
I held her, said nothing. There was nothing left to say.
Next visit, I brought a new mug. Same style. Yellow. Clean. Just two words: Second Chance.
I placed it silently on the shelf where the old one had been. Gina didn’t say anything. Neither did I.
“Tea?” she asked.
“I know what you’re doing,” Hailey said. “It stops here.”
Outside, the kids laughed in the garden.
That mug still sits on the shelf. Untouched. And in the quiet space it leaves behind, something unspoken finally settled:
Not forgiveness. Not forgetting.
But understanding. And maybe, that’s where healing begins.
Leave a Reply